Close
X
Freedom Foundation

Get in touch

Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
  • Blogs
  • Staff
  • Donate
  • Join Us
  • Profiting from a Pandemic
  • Why We Fight
  • Cigars
  • SCOTUS Appeals
Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
Freedom Foundation

Contact Info

Supreme Court Issues Narrow Ruling Against Government Unions in Harris v. Quinn

  • Press
  • June 30, 2014

OLYMPIA, Wash. — It wasn’t the bombshell it might have been, but government employee unions took a major hit on Monday.

In the case of Harris v. Quinn, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a 5-4 ruling stating that home healthcare workers in Illinois should not be considered full-fledged state employees and thus cannot be compelled to either join a union or pay representation fees to one.

The decision does not, however, allow all public employees to disassociate themselves from unions, as many had hoped. Rather, the court creates a category called “partial public employees” who cannot be required to pay union bargaining fees.

Like Illinois, home healthcare workers in Washington are currently represented by unions, including:

  • Service Employees International (SEIU) 925, which has represented 12,000 early learning family childcare providers since 2005; and,
  • SEIU 775, which has represented 26,000 home healthcare workers since 2002.

Presumably the court’s action on Monday means those employees could now be permitted to opt out of union participation altogether – a scenario that could devastate the union if employees here react as they have in other states by opting out in droves.

The plaintiffs, backed by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, had sought a more sweeping decision, one that would overturn Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, a 1977 ruling that affirmed the constitutionality of so-called “agency shops,” in which workers can be fired for refusing to join the union or at least paying a fee for collective bargaining services.

Such a decision would have effectively extended “right-to-work” protections to the 26 states – including Washington – that do not presently have them. The court decided the case more narrowly, but left the door open for future challenges.

“The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision today in Harris v. Quinn is another significant step towards the undoing of compulsory unionism, both in Washington state and the nation,” said Maxford Nelsen, labor policy analyst with the Freedom Foundation, an Olympia-based think and action tank. “It marks a major victory for the First Amendment rights of hundreds of thousands of private-sector workers across the country who have been designated ‘public employees for the purpose of collective bargaining’ only and forcibly unionized.

“Today, the U.S. Supreme Court recognized the forced unionization of home healthcare workers for what it is: a ‘scheme’ designed to fill union coffers at the expense of workers’ First Amendment rights,” Nelsen continued. “SEIU 775, which represents individual home health care providers in Washington, and other unions representing what the Court called ‘partial public employees,’ should immediately do the right thing and allow workers to choose for themselves whether to support union activity.”

The court twice cited the precedents set in its 2007 Davenport v. Washington Education Association ruling, the Freedom Foundation’s lawsuit against the teachers’ union for violation of state laws which protected workers.

Maxford Nelsen can be reached for comment at (360) 956-3482.f

Recent Blogs

Telling the truth even to those who don’t want to hear it
February 3, 2023
DeSantis supports teachers, not their union masters
February 2, 2023
Opt-out windows just another way unions flout Janus ruling
February 2, 2023
Union Politics, Dollars Upended the Ohio State House
January 26, 2023
Freedom Foundation Reaction to Washington State Supreme Court Hearing on Capital Gains Tax
January 26, 2023

Press Articles

  • Jul 06 — RedState — Janus at 4: Landmark Labor Ruling Helped but Still Needs to be Enforced More Aggressively

    Read The Article

  • Jun 28 — Ineptocracy Chronicles — Teacher Unions Fund Left Wing Politics

    Read The Article

  • Jun 25 — The Hill — States Should Protect Caregivers' Medicaid Funds from Union Skims

    Read The Article

  • Jun 15 — Legal Newsline — Freedom Foundation: 'Education Union Spent More Money on Political Activities than Worker Representation'

    Read The Article

  • Jun 09 — Southern California Record — LA Superior Court Court Reporter Accuses Union of Forging Her Signature on Membership Card

    Read The Article

  • General Inquiries

    Info@FreedomFoundation.com

    Media Inquiries

    avarner@freedomfoundation.com

    Follow Us

             

    Contact Locations

    Washington:

    360-956-3482
    P.O. Box 552 Olympia,
    WA 98507

    Pennsylvania:

    484-747-6072
    P.O. Box 1069 Kennett Square,
    PA 19348

    California:

    949-954-8914
    1442 E Lincoln Ave #440 Orange,
    CA 92865

    Oregon:

    503-951-6208
    P.O. Box 18146 Salem,
    OR 97305

    Ohio:

    380-207-3901
    P.O. Box 14210 Cincinnati,
    OH 45250

    © 2021 Freedom Foundation. All Rights Reserved.
    Registered 501(c)(3). EIN: 94-3136961