Close
X
Freedom Foundation

Get in touch

Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
  • Blogs
  • Staff
  • Donate
  • Join Us
  • Profiting from a Pandemic
  • Join Our Team
  • Why We Fight
  • Freedom Foundation Events 2022
Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
Freedom Foundation

Contact Info

Freedom Foundation Asks for Summary Judgment in Capital Gains Tax Lawsuit

Budget & Taxes Litigation Washington
  • Eric Stahlfeld
  • December 15, 2021

After a Douglas County judge in November denied a motion to dismiss the Freedom Foundation’s lawsuit challenging the state of Washington’s new capital gains tax, the organization fired back on Dec. 6 with a motion to expedite the proceedings with a summary judgment.

Douglas County Superior Court will hear arguments on Feb. 4.

The tax in question is a 7 percent assessment on capital gains in excess of $250,000, with numerous loopholes carved out to favor certain groups. 

The gains are based on an individual’s federal personal income tax return — which must be fully disclosed to the state — and it taxes transactions wholly outside Washington, merely because the individual resides within the state. 

The measure is styled as a tax on the “privilege” of selling property, even though the Washington Supreme Court in 1935 rejected a similar legislative attempt to tax the “privilege” of receiving income.

No one can accuse the Left of lacking chutzpah.

In its motion to dismiss, the Freedom Foundation argues that three propositions are indisputable:

  • capital gains are income;
  • income is property; and,
  • a tax on property that is either non-uniform, or at a rate exceeding 1 percent, violates Article VII, Section 1 of the Washington State Constitution. 

The tax also violates the U.S. Constitution because of its effects on interstate commerce.

What’s more, it affects transactions that happen entirely in other states, including those with no nexus to Washington.

It is also unfairly apportioned between Washington and other states, discriminating against interstate commerce, and is imposed on transactions unrelated to any service Washington provides.

Lastly, the tax discriminates against the state constitution’s fundamental right of state residents to be exempt from taxes from which other persons also are exempt.

In this case, the tax is imposed on individuals who report capital gains on their personal federal income tax form, while other “persons” — a designation the tax code generally applies to partnerships, LLC’s, corporations and the like — are exempt. 

The Washington State Legislature, which passed the tax last year, stated its sole purpose is to raise revenue, and there is no justification to treat persons differently.

Just as with its successful fight to defeat Seattle’s income tax in 2020, the Freedom Foundation is working with attorneys at Lane Powell representing 10 plaintiffs.

  • Capital gains

Recent Blogs

Freedom Foundation precedent cited in case challenging COVID regs
July 28, 2022
Devos’s States the Obvious — U.S. Education Department Needs to Be Gone
July 27, 2022
Thwarting Union’s Theft of Vacation Time Was No Small Matter
July 27, 2022
Freedom Foundation a finalist for national award
July 21, 2022
SEIU sues Oregon employee for exposing forgery
July 14, 2022

Press Articles

  • Jul 06 — RedState — Janus at 4: Landmark Labor Ruling Helped but Still Needs to be Enforced More Aggressively

    Read The Article

  • Jun 28 — Ineptocracy Chronicles — Teacher Unions Fund Left Wing Politics

    Read The Article

  • Jun 25 — The Hill — States Should Protect Caregivers' Medicaid Funds from Union Skims

    Read The Article

  • Jun 15 — Legal Newsline — Freedom Foundation: 'Education Union Spent More Money on Political Activities than Worker Representation'

    Read The Article

  • Jun 09 — Southern California Record — LA Superior Court Court Reporter Accuses Union of Forging Her Signature on Membership Card

    Read The Article

  • General Inquiries

    Info@FreedomFoundation.com

    Media Inquiries

    avarner@freedomfoundation.com

    Follow Us

             

    Contact Locations

    Washington:

    360-956-3482
    P.O. Box 552 Olympia,
    WA 98507

    Pennsylvania:

    484-747-6072
    P.O. Box 1069 Kennett Square,
    PA 19348

    California:

    949-954-8914
    1442 E Lincoln Ave #440 Orange,
    CA 92865

    Oregon:

    503-951-6208
    P.O. Box 18146 Salem,
    OR 97305

    Ohio:

    380-207-3901
    P.O. Box 14210 Cincinnati,
    OH 45250

    © 2021 Freedom Foundation. All Rights Reserved.
    Registered 501(c)(3). EIN: 94-3136961