Close
X
Freedom Foundation

Get in touch

Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
  • Blogs
  • Staff
  • Donate
  • Join Us
  • Profiting from a Pandemic
  • Join Our Team
  • Why We Fight
Freedom Foundation
Opt Out Today
Freedom Foundation

Contact Info

AFSCME local throws in the towel 3 hours after being served with papers to stop unconstitutional deductions

Press Release
  • Mike Balascak
  • May 23, 2022

(LOS ANGELES, Calif.) — A Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department employee filed suit on May 16 against the government labor union he once served as vice president, alleging it has refused to honor his request to opt-out based on a union card he signed in the 1990s.

Three hours after being served with Michael Craine’s papers seeking a temporary restraining order, the union quickly sent him a letter agreeing to let him out of the union, stop the deductions and cut him a check.

The union did the right thing — after being hauled into federal court, that is.

Michael Craine, a helicopter mechanic with the department for 23 years, informed the union in January of his wish to end his membership and $55 monthly dues payments.

Craine joined the American Federation of County, State and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 19 when he was hired in 1999, and the membership form and dues authorization Craine signed clearly stated he could leave at any time merely by submitting a “written notice.”

Craine says he never wanted to join the union and was always angered that AFSCME wasted so much its time and his dues money involving itself in partisan political battles that had nothing to do with employee wages and working conditions.

His concerns led him to run for union office, and he served as Local 119’s vice president from 2014 to 2017.

Craine finally lost patience with AFSCME in January, when the union raised no objection to a policy requiring county employees to be vaccinated for the COVID-19 virus.

“AFSCME had to choose between standing up for the rights of its members and siding with an intrusive, big-government agenda,” said Timothy R. Snowball, an attorney with the Freedom Foundation, which is providing Craine with pro bono legal representation.

When Craine sent the required written notice in January 2022, he was informed that, under provisions of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) worked out by Los Angeles County and AFSCME 119, he could only opt out during an annual two-week annual window not scheduled to re-open until September 2022.

The catch is that Craine was never a party to the MOU between the union and the county. And even if he had been, the agreement had already expired by the time his request was submitted.

Craine’s lawsuit argues that his union card from 1999 controls his ability to end both his membership and the deductions, and any money taken after submission of his opt-out notice and spent by the union on political speech without contract or consent was a violation of the First Amendment.

“AFSCME clearly knows it doesn’t have a leg to stand on,” Snowball added. “Whether we’re talking about a membership card from the last century or an expired MOU, Mr. Craine has the constitutional right to decide whether a union can take his money and spend it on politics.”

“Otherwise, why would the union have caved so quickly?” he concluded. “It’s about making the process of leaving the union as painful as possible to discourage anyone else who might be considering it.”

The suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, names AFSCME Local 119, Los Angeles County, and California Attorney General Rob Bonta as defendants.

In addition to seeking a refund of the dues improperly deducted in the months since he submitted his opt-out request, Craine also seeks damages for his constitutional injuries and a permanent injunction preventing AFSCME 119 from continuing the practice in the future.

Recent Blogs

Freedom Foundation CEO Statement Celebrating the Fourth Anniversary of Janus v. AFSCME
June 27, 2022
Lawsuit challenges AOCE’s opt-out bluff
June 23, 2022
Lawsuit alleges union denying ‘fair representation’ to nonmembers
June 23, 2022
Biden cozies up to his union handlers
June 15, 2022
Survey of Connecticut teachers reveals teachers’ true opinion of union activities
June 15, 2022

Press Articles

  • Jan 31 — The Federalist — The Federalist – Report: Washington Is Inflating COVID Death Tolls, Even After Getting Caught Once Before

    Read The Article

  • Dec 18 — Ricochet — Ricochet – You Can’t Handle the Truth, or Numbers

    Read The Article

  • Dec 18 — Fox News Radio — More evidence states inflating numbers of COVID deaths

    Read The Article

  • Dec 01 — KFLD News Talk — Investigation Shows WSDOH Still ‘Inflating’ COVID Death Counts

    Read The Article

  • General Inquiries

    Info@FreedomFoundation.com

    Media Inquiries

    avarner@freedomfoundation.com

    Follow Us

             

    Contact Locations

    Washington:

    360-956-3482
    P.O. Box 552 Olympia,
    WA 98507

    Pennsylvania:

    484-747-6072
    P.O. Box 1069 Kennett Square,
    PA 19348

    California:

    949-954-8914
    1442 E Lincoln Ave #440 Orange,
    CA 92865

    Oregon:

    503-951-6208
    P.O. Box 18146 Salem,
    OR 97305

    Ohio:

    380-207-3901
    P.O. Box 14210 Cincinnati,
    OH 45250

    © 2021 Freedom Foundation. All Rights Reserved.
    Registered 501(c)(3). EIN: 94-3136961